Reimagining India's Apex Court: The Case for Dividing the Supreme Court's Workload
An examination of the growing backlog in the Supreme Court of India and the proposal to bifurcate its functions into a dedicated Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal.
The Supreme Court's Escalating Backlog and Constitutional Dilution
The Supreme Court of India is currently grappling with an unprecedented and escalating backlog of cases. This significantly impacts its ability to effectively discharge its constitutional duties. As of the close of 2025, the court recorded 92,318 pending cases, marking its heaviest backlog ever. This represents an increase of nearly 10,000 cases compared to the previous year (Source: The Hindu, November 14, 2026). This substantial and growing caseload has led to concerns that the apex court's primary function—safeguarding the Republic's foundational document—is being diluted. Constitutional matters are increasingly "drowning in ordinary appeals" (Source: The Hindu, November 14, 2026).
The gravity of this situation was highlighted in 2016 when three Supreme Court judges formally posed 11 questions about the institution's trajectory. They referred the matter to a larger Bench for consideration. A decade later, this crucial reference remains unheard, underscoring the systemic nature of the problem and the difficulty in addressing it through conventional means.
Proposal for Bifurcating the Supreme Court's Workload
In response to the persistent and growing judicial backlog, a significant proposal advocates for the structural bifurcation of the Supreme Court's workload into two distinct divisions. This remedy, articulated by Pradeep Mehta and Vijay Kelkar, suggests the creation of a "lean Constitutional Court" comprising approximately 11 judges. This court would be exclusively located in Delhi (Source: The Hindu, November 14, 2026).
The mandate of this specialized court would be to hear only "constitutional cases and substantial questions of law." This would allow focused attention on matters of national importance and constitutional interpretation (Source: The Hindu, November 14, 2026). Complementing this, the proposal envisions the establishment of "four or five regional Courts of Appeal" across the country (Source: The Hindu, November 14, 2026). These regional courts would be tasked with handling the vast volume of "appeals that now flood the apex court." These primarily consist of Special Leave Petitions (SLPs) filed under Article 136 of the Constitution, along with other routine appellate matters (Source: The Hindu, November 14, 2026).
Keep reading this explainer
This is the opening of a 1769-word explainer. An account brings you the rest, a PDF to keep and the whole Explained archive.
Takes about a minute. Your email and a password is all it needs.