The Tenth Schedule's Enduring Challenge: Can India's Anti-Defection Law Be Fixed?
Four decades after its enactment, the anti-defection law is being tested by novel political strategies, raising fundamental questions about its efficacy in ensuring legislative stability and respecting electoral mandates.
What is the core purpose of the Tenth Schedule?
The Tenth Schedule was introduced into the Constitution via the 52nd Amendment Act in 1985 with the stated objective of combating “the evil of political defections.” The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Bill noted that defections induce political corruption and undermine democracy by betraying the people's mandate. The law provides for the disqualification of a member of Parliament or a State Legislature on two main grounds. Under Paragraph 2(1)(a), disqualification applies if they voluntarily give up the membership of their political party. Under Paragraph 2(1)(b), it applies if they vote or abstain from voting in the House contrary to a direction, or 'whip', issued by their party without prior permission.
The law was designed to bring stability to governments by preventing legislators from switching parties after being elected on a particular party's ticket. By linking a legislator's membership of the House to their continued loyalty to their party, the law sought to make defection a costly affair. This was intended to strengthen party discipline and ensure that governments could serve their full term without the constant threat of being toppled by floor-crossing.
How have recent events in Maharashtra tested the law?
Political developments in Maharashtra have exposed significant grey areas in the Tenth Schedule, enabling manoeuvres that challenge the law's spirit. The case of Sachin Ahir, a Shiv Sena (UBT) leader, is a prime example. On June 30, 2024, he switched allegiance to the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena and was elected Deputy Chairperson of the Maharashtra Legislative Council the next day (Source: The Hindu). Ahir, like Neelam Gorhe who made a similar switch on July 7, 2023, argued that he had not defected. He claimed he was elected as a Shiv Sena MLC in 2022, before the party's vertical split, and that legislative records still show him as a member of the 'Shiv Sena', not a specific faction. This argument leverages the ECI's February 2023 decision to grant the original party name and symbol to the Shinde faction.
Keep reading this explainer
This is the opening of a 1824-word explainer. An account brings you the rest, a PDF to keep and the whole Explained archive.
Takes about a minute. Your email and a password is all it needs.